Which of the following legal act of nursing comes under Negligence?

AIIMS Raipur NO - 2019 (Shift-1)

Forensic Nursing & Indian laws

Medium

Appeared in: AIIMS Raipur NO - 2019 (Shift-1)

Explanation

Negligence is an unintentional tort, meaning it's a failure to provide the standard of care without the intent to cause harm.
A medication error, such as giving the wrong drug or dose, is a classic example of a breach in the standard of nursing care.
This act is typically a result of carelessness or a system failure, not a willful decision to harm, which aligns perfectly with the legal definition of negligence.
Other options like invasion of privacy and false documentation are classified as intentional torts because they involve deliberate actions.

Option A: While failing to report a change in a patient's condition is a serious breach of duty and a form of professional negligence (malpractice), medication error is a more direct and universally cited example of negligence itself.
Option B: Invasion of privacy is classified as an intentional tort, not negligence. It involves a willful act that violates a patient's right to privacy, such as sharing their health information without consent.
Option C: False documentation is an act of fraud, which is an intentional tort. It involves deliberately falsifying records, which is a willful act of deception, not an unintentional lapse in care like negligence.

Clinical Relevance

Nursing practice connection: Knowing Understanding the legal definition of negligence in nursing practice and differentiating it from other legal violations like intentional torts helps nurses interpret findings accurately and avoid errors in routine assessment, medication administration, and patient teaching.
Adhering to the 'Five Rights' of medication administration (Right Patient, Right Drug, Right Dose, Right Route, Right Time) is a fundamental nursing intervention to prevent medication errors and avoid negligence claims.
Accurate and timely documentation is a legal safeguard. It provides proof that the standard of care was met. Remember the principle: 'If it wasn't documented, it wasn't done.'.
What if? If a nurse knowingly administers a placebo instead of a prescribed pain medication and documents it as the actual medication, the act transitions from simple negligence to an intentional tort (fraud and potentially battery), carrying more severe legal consequences.

How to Approach the Question

First, understand the core concept of the question, which is 'Negligence' in a legal nursing context.
Define negligence in your mind: It's an unintentional failure to provide the standard of care, a 'careless' mistake that causes harm.
Analyze each option to determine if the act is intentional or unintentional.
Option A (Failing to report) and D (Medication error) are unintentional lapses in care.
Option B (Invasion of privacy) and C (False documentation) are intentional acts.
Eliminate the intentional torts (B and C).

Concept Tested & Keywords

Concept Tested: Understanding the legal definition of negligence in nursing practice and differentiating it from other legal violations like intentional torts.
Stem keywords: legal act, nursing, Negligence
Lead-in keywords: Which of the following

QUs0TPDFECmH8F4TkeUJGK

E6 Nursing_Management_and_leadership_Johny_Kutty_JosephCbs_Publishers (pp 16-364 of 374) p. 334-336

E6 Textbook of Nursing Management and Leadership I. Clemen — Subpart C (pp 655-967 of 982) p. 274-276