NORCET-10 Mains
Forensic Nursing & Indian laws
Medium

A person kills his friend because of his belief that he will poison him & later he was diagnosed as a case of schizophrenia. He was taken to court. Based on McNaughten’s rule how is person liable for crime?

Appeared in: NORCET-10 Mains

Explanation

  • McNaughten's rule states a person is not legally responsible if, due to mental illness, they did not know the nature or wrongfulness of the act.
  • Schizophrenia can cause delusions, making the person unable to understand their actions.
  • If proven, the person is found not guilty by reason of insanity and is not held criminally liable.
  • Section 84 IPC in India is based on McNaughten's rule.

Why Other Options Were Wrong

  • Option A: Partial guilt is not recognized under McNaughten's rule. The law either finds the person criminally responsible or not, based on their mental state.
  • Option B: A person with proven insanity at the time of the act is not considered guilty under McNaughten's rule, as they lack the required mental intent (mens rea).
  • Option D: This option is a partial restatement of the rule, but McNaughten's rule specifically requires that the person did not know the act was wrong, not just that they knew it was wrong.

Related Visual

  • No visual required for this question type.
Clinical Relevance
  • Nursing practice connection: Prioritize focused assessment, early escalation, and real-time monitoring when managing Application of McNaughten's rule for criminal responsibility in mental illness in acute care settings.
  • Nurses must understand legal protections for mentally ill patients, especially in forensic settings.
  • Recognizing signs of psychosis or delusions can help prevent harm and ensure proper legal procedures.
  • What if? If the person knew the act was wrong or understood its nature, they would be held criminally responsible, even with a mental illness diagnosis.
How to Approach the Question
  • Identify the legal rule being referenced (McNaughten's rule).
  • Recall the criteria for criminal responsibility under this rule.
  • Match the scenario (schizophrenia, delusions, lack of understanding) to the rule's requirements.
  • Eliminate options that do not fit the strict criteria of McNaughten's rule.
  • Choose the answer that aligns with the legal definition of insanity defense.
Concept Tested & Keywords
  • Concept Tested: Application of McNaughten's rule for criminal responsibility in mental illness
  • Stem keywords: kills friend, belief of poisoning, schizophrenia, court, McNaughten’s rule
  • Lead-in keywords: liable for crime
  • Clinical cues: diagnosed with schizophrenia
  • Clinical cues: delusional belief

Question ID

QFYRXxzZDTeRabeYKgmOmb

Reference Book

E6 Guide to Mental Health & PSYCHIATRIC NURSING R Sreevani— Part 2 (pp 290-564 of 579) p. 123-125

E6 Kaplan Sadock's Synopsis of Psychiatry-2022 (pp 1-3768 of 3768) pp. 2655-2657, 2657-2659

Practise the full NORCET-10 Mains

Attempt every question from this paper in a timed mock, then review the full solution for each one.

More Forensic Psychiatry Questions

More NORCET-10 Mains Questions