A patient says to a nurse, "Everyone would be better off if I wasn't alive." Which nursing diagnosis would be made based on this statement?

Appeared in: JODHPUR AIIMS SNO-2018

Explanation

The patient's statement is a direct verbal cue for suicidal ideation, indicating feelings of worthlessness and a desire to die.
The nursing diagnosis 'Risk for self-directed violence' specifically addresses the vulnerability of an individual to harm themselves.
According to nursing principles, safety is the highest priority. This diagnosis flags an immediate and life-threatening risk that must be addressed before other psychosocial issues.

Option B: While the patient is likely experiencing ineffective coping, this diagnosis is less urgent than the immediate risk of self-harm. Safety diagnoses always take precedence.
Option C: The patient's single statement about their own worth does not provide sufficient evidence to diagnose a problem with social interaction. It reflects an internal state, not necessarily their social skills or relationships.
Option D: This diagnosis relates to disruptions in thought content and processing, such as delusions, hallucinations, or disorganized thinking. The patient's statement, while a sign of severe depression, is a clear expression of a feeling, not a disordered thought process.

Clinical Relevance

Nursing practice connection: Use the key finding related to Prioritization of Nursing Diagnoses in Mental Health to guide bedside assessment, documentation, and the next nursing action.
A nurse must be able to recognize both direct and indirect cues of suicidal ideation. Any statement suggesting hopelessness, worthlessness, or a desire to die must be taken seriously.
The immediate nursing priority is always patient safety. This involves creating a safe environment, providing constant observation, and communicating urgently with the healthcare team.
What if the patient said, 'I'm so tired of fighting, I just wish it would all end'? The nursing diagnosis would remain 'Risk for self-directed violence.' Even though the statement is less direct, it is a strong indirect cue for suicide and must be treated with the same level of urgency.

How to Approach the Question

First, analyze the patient's statement: "Everyone would be better off if I wasn't alive." Identify the core emotion and intent, which is hopelessness and a veiled reference to suicide.
Next, consider the principle of prioritizing nursing diagnoses. Remember the hierarchy: safety (like risk for violence) comes before psychosocial needs (like coping or social interaction).
Evaluate each option against the patient's statement and the priority principle.
Option A, 'Risk for self-directed violence,' directly addresses the safety threat implied by the patient's words.
Option B, 'Ineffective coping,' is likely true but is a lower priority than the immediate risk of harm.
Options C and D are not directly supported by the information given. The statement is about self-worth, not social skills or thought disorganization.

Concept Tested & Keywords

Concept Tested: Prioritization of Nursing Diagnoses in Mental Health
Stem keywords: patient statement, nursing diagnosis, suicidal ideation
Lead-in keywords: which nursing diagnosis
Clinical cues: Patient statement: "Everyone would be better off if I wasn't alive."

QENWIhziKuVwLT8Z_DUI3N

E6 Guide to Mental Health & PSYCHIATRIC NURSING R Sreevani— Part 1 (pp 26-289 of 579) p. 217-219

E6 Nursing Fundamentals Potter Perry 12e Part 4 p. 66-68

Practise the full JODHPUR AIIMS SNO-2018

Attempt every question from this paper in a timed mock, then review the full solution for each one.