Which of the following places was NOT visited by the 'Simon Commission'?

Appeared in: UPPSC 2022

Explanation

The Simon Commission's mandate was to review the constitutional system in British India only.
Gwalior was a princely state, not a British Indian province, and therefore fell outside the commission's jurisdiction.
Relations with princely states were handled by a separate body, the Butler Committee (Indian States Committee).

Option A: Shillong was the capital of the Assam province, which was part of British India. The commission visited provincial capitals as part of its tour.
Option B: At the time of the commission's visit, Burma (now Myanmar) was administered as a province of British India. Therefore, its capital, Rangoon, was included in the tour.
Option C: Madras (now Chennai) was the capital of the Madras Presidency, one of the most important administrative divisions of British India, and was a key stop for the commission.

Clinical Relevance

Nursing practice connection: This is primarily an exam-oriented knowledge point with limited direct bedside application, so retain Historical geography of the Simon Commission's tour as background academic context rather than a clinical decision trigger.
Understanding the distinction between British India and the princely states is crucial for comprehending the political and administrative landscape of the era.
The Simon Commission's all-white composition and the subsequent boycott are landmark events that significantly intensified the Indian independence movement.
What if? - If the commission had included Indian members, the widespread boycotts might have been averted, potentially altering the course and timeline of constitutional negotiations and the path to independence.

How to Approach the Question

First, identify the core subject of the question, which is the Simon Commission's tour in India.
Note the negative keyword 'NOT'. This indicates that you need to find the location from the options that was an exception and was not visited.
Recall or deduce the primary mandate of the Simon Commission. Its purpose was to review the constitution for 'British India'.
Analyze each option based on its political status in the late 1920s. Determine whether each location was part of British India or a princely state.
Shillong, Rangoon, and Madras were all administrative centers within British India. Gwalior was a princely state.
Based on the commission's mandate, it would not have officially visited a princely state. Therefore, Gwalior is the correct answer.

Concept Tested & Keywords

Concept Tested: Historical geography of the Simon Commission's tour
Stem keywords: Simon Commission, visited
Lead-in keywords: NOT
Negative lead-in flag: The question asks to identify the location that was NOT visited by the Simon Commission, requiring elimination of the places it did visit.

QeVSuQoCik_yFcEQUrfb26

Practise the full UPPSC 2022

Attempt every question from this paper in a timed mock, then review the full solution for each one.