MNS 2015
Reasoning
Medium

Air : Atmosphere :: Water...?

Appeared in: MNS 2015

Explanation

  • The question presents an analogy where the relationship between the first pair of words must be applied to the second pair.
  • The relationship is 'Component : Whole' or 'Substance : Environment'.
  • Air is the primary substance that makes up the Atmosphere.
  • Following this pattern, Water is the primary substance that makes up the Sea.
  • Thus, 'Sea' is the logical counterpart to 'Atmosphere' in this analogy.

Why Other Options Were Wrong

  • Option A: This option, 'Air', is the component from the first part of the analogy. It does not represent the 'whole' or 'environment' for water.
  • Option B: This option, 'Atmosphere', is the 'whole' from the first part of the analogy. The question asks for the 'whole' that corresponds to water, not air.
  • Option C: This option, 'Water', is the component or substance itself. The analogy requires finding the 'whole' that is made of this substance, not repeating the substance.

Related Visual

Visual explanation — Related Visual
Clinical Relevance
  • Nursing practice connection: This is primarily an exam-oriented knowledge point with limited direct bedside application, so retain Analogical Reasoning as background academic context rather than a clinical decision trigger.
  • This is a general intelligence question designed to test logical and analogical reasoning skills, which are important for problem-solving in any field, including nursing.
  • While not directly clinical, the ability to see relationships and patterns is crucial for making diagnostic connections and understanding cause-and-effect in patient care.
  • What if? - If the stem changed one defining clue so that Sea no longer matched, reassess the option whose mechanism, classification, or indication now fits the revised presentation.
How to Approach the Question
  • First, identify the relationship between the first pair of words: 'Air' and 'Atmosphere'.
  • Recognize that air is the primary substance that makes up the atmosphere. The relationship is 'part-to-whole' or 'substance-to-location'.
  • Next, apply this same relationship to the second word, 'Water'.
  • Ask yourself: 'Water is the primary substance that makes up what?'
  • Evaluate the given options to find the one that represents a large body or expanse composed of water.
  • Eliminate options that don't fit the 'whole' concept (like 'Water' itself) or belong to the first pair ('Air', 'Atmosphere').
Concept Tested & Keywords
  • Concept Tested: Analogical Reasoning
  • Stem keywords: Air, Atmosphere, Water, Analogy
  • Lead-in keywords: BEST, MOST RELEVANT CLUE

Question ID

QfgQhRUVcJXdnXKVAP2H9C

Practise the full MNS 2015

Attempt every question from this paper in a timed mock, then review the full solution for each one.