A nursing department in an acute care setting decides to redesign its nursing practice based on a theoretical framework. The feedback from patients, families, and staff reflects that caring is a key element. Which theorist best supports this concept?

1. A

   Brisson

2. B

   Maslow

3. C

   Rogers

4. D

   Watson

Appeared in: JIPMER Nursing Officer-2024

Explanation

• Jean Watson's theory is titled the 'Theory of Human Caring' or 'Transpersonal Caring', making it the most direct fit for a practice model based on caring.
• The theory posits that caring is the central, unifying, and dominant domain that characterizes nursing practice.
• Watson's framework focuses on the nurse-patient relationship and the therapeutic effect of the caring process, which aligns with the feedback received by the nursing department.
• It integrates a holistic approach, viewing the patient's health in the context of their overall harmony of mind, body, and spirit, which is achieved through caring relationships.

Why Other Options Were Wrong

• Option A: Brisson is not a recognized major nursing theorist. Foundational nursing theories are well-documented, and Brisson is not among the key figures like Watson, Orem, Roy, or Peplau.
• Option B: Abraham Maslow was a psychologist, not a nurse theorist. His Hierarchy of Needs is a theory of human motivation that is widely applied in nursing to prioritize patient needs (e.g., physiological safety before self-esteem), but it is not a nursing framework centered on the concept of caring.
• Option C: Martha Rogers developed the 'Science of Unitary Human Beings'. This is a highly abstract theory that views the person as an energy field. Its focus is on the human-environment energy exchange and patterns, not on the interpersonal and compassionate aspects of caring.

Related Visual

• Visual 1: Concept Map - A diagram illustrating the 10 Carative Factors of Watson's Theory of Human Caring, showing how each factor contributes to the central theme of transpersonal caring.
• Visual 2: Comparison Chart - A table comparing the core concepts of major nursing theorists (Watson, Orem, Roy, Leininger, Rogers) to highlight their different focuses (Caring, Self-Care, Adaptation, Culture, Energy Fields).

Clinical Relevance

• Nursing practice connection: Knowing Nursing Theories and Frameworks helps nurses interpret findings accurately and avoid errors in routine assessment, medication administration, and patient teaching.
• Adopting a caring framework like Watson's can lead to improved patient satisfaction scores, as patients feel heard, respected, and valued as individuals.
• A focus on caring can reduce nurse burnout and increase job satisfaction by reconnecting nurses with the core values of their profession, fostering a more positive work environment.
• What if the feedback had emphasized patient independence and ability to manage their own health? In that case, Dorothea Orem's Self-Care Deficit Theory, which focuses on helping patients achieve self-care, would have been a more appropriate framework.

How to Approach the Question

• First, identify the core concept in the question's stem. Here, the keyword is 'caring'.
• Next, review the options provided, which are all names of theorists.
• Recall or look up the primary focus of each theorist's work.
• Match the core concept from the stem ('caring') with the theorist whose work is most centered on that concept.
• Eliminate theorists whose work focuses on other concepts (e.g., hierarchy of needs, energy fields). Watson's theory is explicitly about caring, making it the best fit.

Concept Tested & Keywords

• Concept Tested: Nursing Theories and Frameworks
• Stem keywords: nursing practice, theoretical framework, caring, acute care
• Lead-in keywords: best supports
• Clinical cues: Feedback from patients, families, and staff reflects that caring is a key element.

Question ID

Q5DaMI6gzZGl5rv1ztSlQ3

Copy ID