Which of the following is a barrier to therapeutic communication?

RUHS, Jaipur, M.Sc Nursing Entrance Exam-2022

Nursing Foundation

Easy

Appeared in: RUHS, Jaipur, M.Sc Nursing Entrance Exam-2022

Explanation

Giving advice is a non-therapeutic communication technique that acts as a barrier.
It imposes the nurse's opinion on the patient, which can block the patient from expressing their own feelings and making their own decisions.
This approach undermines the patient's capability for self-direction and problem-solving, which is contrary to the goals of therapeutic communication.
Effective therapeutic communication encourages patients to explore their own ideas and come to their own conclusions.

Option A: Focusing is a therapeutic technique, not a barrier. It is used to guide the patient to concentrate on a single important point, which helps make the conversation more goal-directed.
Option C: Restating is a therapeutic technique. It involves the nurse repeating the main thought the patient has expressed to show they are listening and to validate the patient's statement.
Option D: Active listening is the foundation of therapeutic communication, not a barrier. It involves being fully attentive to both the verbal and non-verbal messages of the patient.

Clinical Relevance

Nursing practice connection: This is primarily an exam-oriented knowledge point with limited direct bedside application, so retain Barriers to Therapeutic Communication as background academic context rather than a clinical decision trigger.
Mastering therapeutic communication is essential for building a strong nurse-patient relationship, which is built on trust and respect.
Effective communication improves patient satisfaction, promotes adherence to treatment plans, and leads to better health outcomes.
What if a patient directly asks, 'What should I do?' A therapeutic response is not to give advice but to use reflection. The nurse could say, 'That's a good question. What options have you been considering?' This returns the focus to the patient, empowering them to find their own solution.

How to Approach the Question

First, identify the key concept in the question stem, which is 'barrier to therapeutic communication'. This means you are looking for a negative action or a non-therapeutic technique.
Next, analyze each option to determine its nature. Classify each one as either a therapeutic (helpful) technique or a non-therapeutic (hindering) action.
Evaluate 'Focusing': This is a technique to guide conversation, which is helpful. So, it's therapeutic.
Evaluate 'Giving advice': This involves telling the patient what to do, which can shut down their own thought process. This is a barrier.
Evaluate 'Restating' and 'Listening': Both are fundamental techniques for showing engagement and understanding. They are therapeutic.
Conclude that 'Giving advice' is the only option that functions as a barrier, making it the correct answer.

Concept Tested & Keywords

QE0GSTjxEr_vnoPNnZGUAP

E6 Guide to Mental Health & PSYCHIATRIC NURSING R Sreevani— Part 1 (pp 26-289 of 579) pp. 102-104, 100-102