Five students participated in a Quiz Programme. Prithvi ranked higher than Smriti. Smriti ranked higher then Pranav. Prithvi ranked lower than Alvira. Madhura's rank is in between prathivi and smriti. Who is the highest in rank.

Appeared in: ESIC Nursing Officer 2016 (Shift -2)

Explanation

The question requires arranging five students based on their relative ranks described in four conditions.
The statement 'Prithvi ranked lower than Alvira' directly establishes that Alvira's rank is higher than Prithvi's.
Subsequent conditions place all other students (Madhura, Smriti, and Pranav) at ranks lower than Prithvi.
By combining all conditions, a single order is formed: Alvira > Prithvi > Madhura > Smriti > Pranav.
This logical chain confirms that Alvira holds the number one position, making her the highest in rank.

Option A: Prithvi cannot be the highest because the prompt explicitly states, 'Prithvi ranked lower than Alvira,' meaning Alvira is ranked higher than Prithvi.
Option C: Smriti's rank is lower than Prithvi's and Madhura's, as established by the conditions 'Prithvi ranked higher than Smriti' and 'Madhura's rank is in between Prithvi and Smriti'.
Option D: Madhura's rank is between Prithvi and Smriti. This means Prithvi (and by extension, Alvira) is ranked higher than Madhura.

Clinical Relevance

Nursing practice connection: This is primarily an exam-oriented knowledge point with limited direct bedside application, so retain Logical Reasoning and Ranking as background academic context rather than a clinical decision trigger.
While not a clinical question, logical reasoning is a critical skill for nurses in prioritizing tasks, interpreting complex patient data, and making sound clinical judgments under pressure.
This type of step-by-step problem-solving mirrors the process of differential diagnosis or creating a care plan based on multiple patient symptoms and lab values.
What if the prompt stated 'Alvira's rank is in between Smriti and Pranav'? The order would become Prithvi > Madhura > Smriti > Alvira > Pranav, making Prithvi the highest-ranked student.

How to Approach the Question

First, identify all the individuals involved in the ranking puzzle: Prithvi, Smriti, Pranav, Alvira, and Madhura.
Translate each statement into a simple inequality. For example, 'Prithvi ranked higher than Smriti' becomes 'Prithvi > Smriti'.
Combine these inequalities one by one to build a single, continuous chain of ranks.
Carefully place individuals with 'in-between' ranks (like Madhura) into the correct position within the established chain.
Once the final, complete order is determined, identify the student at the very top of the chain to find the highest rank.

Concept Tested & Keywords

Q9f9QifhmfGEOm_nnyvs3p

Practise the full ESIC Nursing Officer 2016 (Shift -2)

Attempt every question from this paper in a timed mock, then review the full solution for each one.