Which of the following action guiding theory explains that the rightness or wrongness of an action depends on the consequences of the action?

Appeared in: AIIMS Bhuvneshwar NO- 2018

Explanation

The Utilitarian theory, also known as consequentialism, judges the morality of an action based on its outcomes.
It holds that an action is right if it promotes the best consequences, defined as the greatest amount of good for the greatest number of people.
This theory focuses on the 'ends' rather than the 'means' or the inherent nature of the act itself.

Option A: The Deontologic theory bases morality on adherence to duties and rules, not on the consequences of an action. An action is judged by its intrinsic rightness, not its outcome.
Option C: Non-maleficence is an ethical principle, not an overarching ethical theory. It is a specific rule of conduct ('do no harm') within broader ethical frameworks.
Option D: Beneficence is also an ethical principle, not a theory. It is a rule of conduct ('do good') that guides professionals to act in the best interests of their patients.

Visual 1: Flowchart - A flowchart comparing the decision-making process for a moral dilemma from a Utilitarian perspective (weighing outcomes) versus a Deontological perspective (applying rules).

Clinical Relevance

Nursing practice connection: This is primarily an exam-oriented knowledge point with limited direct bedside application, so retain Ethical Theories in Nursing as background academic context rather than a clinical decision trigger.
Nurses frequently face ethical dilemmas where different theories suggest different actions. For example, deciding whether to tell a terminally ill patient their full prognosis involves weighing the deontological duty of truth-telling against the utilitarian goal of minimizing suffering.
Understanding these theories helps nurses analyze complex situations, justify their decisions, and communicate their ethical reasoning to the healthcare team and patients' families.
What if? If a new hospital policy benefits the majority of patients (a utilitarian good) but significantly burdens a small, vulnerable patient group, a nurse guided by deontology might object based on the duty to care for each individual, highlighting the conflict between these theories in practice.

How to Approach the Question

First, identify the key phrase in the question: 'depends on the consequences of the action'.
Next, recall the definitions of the major ethical theories and principles provided in the options.
Match the key phrase 'consequences' to the definition of each option.
Recognize that Utilitarianism is the theory directly concerned with consequences or outcomes.
Differentiate between ethical theories (like Utilitarianism and Deontology), which provide a framework for what is right and wrong, and ethical principles (like Beneficence and Non-maleficence), which are specific rules of conduct.

Concept Tested & Keywords

Concept Tested: Ethical Theories in Nursing
Stem keywords: action guiding theory, rightness or wrongness, consequences of the action
Lead-in keywords: Which
Negative lead-in flag: false

Qk3nEOWTqnSBWgXBB9fOFW

Practise the full AIIMS Bhuvneshwar NO- 2018

Attempt every question from this paper in a timed mock, then review the full solution for each one.