Patients in rural settings may not have the same access to healthcare services as those in metropolitan areas. This disparity represents a violation of which ethical principle?

1. A

   Autonomy

2. B

   Justice

3. C

   Non-maleficence

4. D

   Beneficence

Appeared in: KGMU 2023

Explanation

• The principle of justice in healthcare refers to fairness in the distribution of resources and care.
• A disparity in healthcare access between rural and urban populations is a classic example of a violation of distributive justice.
• Justice requires that all individuals have an equal opportunity to access healthcare services, regardless of their geographic location.

Why Other Options Were Wrong

• Option A: Autonomy is about respecting a patient's right to make their own decisions (e.g., informed consent). The question is about systemic access to care, not an individual's choice.
• Option C: Non-maleficence is the principle of 'do no harm'. While lack of access can lead to harm, the core ethical violation in a system of unequal distribution is injustice.
• Option D: Beneficence is the duty to act for the benefit of others. The question describes a failure to distribute benefits fairly (a justice issue), not a failure to act for a specific patient's good.

Related Visual

• Visual 1: Infographic - A chart comparing the four main ethical principles (Justice, Autonomy, Beneficence, Non-maleficence) with simple definitions and icons to illustrate each concept.
• Visual 2: Map - A map of a country showing the disparity in the number of hospitals or specialized clinics between urban centers and rural areas to visually represent the concept of distributive injustice.

Clinical Relevance

• Nursing practice connection: This is primarily an exam-oriented knowledge point with limited direct bedside application, so retain Application of Ethical Principles in Nursing as background academic context rather than a clinical decision trigger.
• Nurses have an ethical responsibility to act as advocates for their patients and communities. This includes advocating for policies that promote health equity and reduce disparities in access to care.
• Understanding the principle of justice helps nurses recognize and address systemic barriers that prevent certain populations from receiving the care they need.
• What if? If a rural patient had access to a clinic but refused a recommended treatment, the primary ethical principle in play would shift from Justice to Autonomy (respecting the patient's right to refuse).

How to Approach the Question

• First, read the question carefully to identify the core issue. The key concepts here are 'disparity' and unequal 'access to healthcare' between two different populations (rural vs. metropolitan).
• Next, review the four options, which are all major ethical principles in healthcare.
• Analyze each principle's definition. Autonomy is about choice, Beneficence is about doing good, Non-maleficence is about avoiding harm, and Justice is about fairness and equitable distribution.
• Match the core issue from the question to the most relevant principle. The problem of unequal distribution of services directly aligns with the definition of Justice.
• Therefore, select Justice as the principle being violated.

Concept Tested & Keywords

• Concept Tested: Application of Ethical Principles in Nursing
• Stem keywords: rural settings, access to healthcare, disparity, metropolitan areas
• Lead-in keywords: violation, ethical principle
• Negative lead-in flag: false

Question ID

QJ5Lx2YIrAFSvN-kkvMKnm

Copy ID